Chapter 2 - The Shoebox of Lies
By mid-January, the bitter northern cold had locked the town of Oakhaven in iron and ice. Snowdrifts piled five feet high against the white picket fence surrounding Edith’s Victorian home on Elm Street.
Inside, the only sound was the rhythmic ticking of the grandfather clock and the crackle of dry oak in the woodstove. Edith sat at her kitchen table, a glass of water and a pair of reading glasses beside her. In front of her sat a vintage green shoebox—the repository of twenty-four years of family history.
Beside the shoebox lay the morning mail. Three envelopes.
Edith picked up the first one. It was thick, heavy linen paper, perfumed with vanilla and stamped with a gold wax seal. Brittany’s handwriting on the front was ornate, looping, and unmistakably artificial.
Edith used a bone letter opener to slice the top.
*“Dearest Grandmother,”* the note began, written with black fountain pen ink. *“My heart has not known peace since Christmas morning. I have wept every night thinking of how terribly my actions must have appeared to your gentle heart. Social media and the pressures of youth blinded me to the simple sacredness of family. Enclosed is a small token of my repentance—a dried lavender sachet from my trip to Napa. I love you more than words, and I pray every day that you find it in your heart to forgive your foolish, loving granddaughter. P.S. I would love to bring you some gluten-free bakery treats this Tuesday afternoon to keep you company.”*
Edith read it once. Her face was entirely blank. She picked up a magnifying glass and examined the handwriting. The looping curves were hurried, the ink uneven—drafted rapidly, likely between takes of whatever cosmetics advertisement Brittany was shooting for her channel.
Edith set it down and picked up the second envelope. It was standard blue-lined stationery, the paper crinkled at the edges. Josh.
*“Grandma,”* the letter read in rushed, erratic scrawl. *“I am so sorry about Christmas. I was just joking around, you know how Brittany and I get into that sibling rhythm. I’ve been doing a lot of thinking about Grandfather and the legacy of Palmer Feed. In fact, I’ve been talking to some angel investors about an agricultural tech startup that honors his name. I would love to come by and show you the business plan. Family is everything to me, Grandma. You’re the rock of this family. Call me anytime, I’ll drop everything and come over.”*
Edith folded the letter back into its creases. She knew from her contact at the town bank that Josh’s checking account was currently overdrawn by four thousand dollars, and that two men in an unmarked sedan with out-of-state plates had been seen idling outside his apartment complex twice this week. Josh wasn't looking to honor his grandfather; he was looking for a shield against a broken kneecap.
Finally, she opened the third envelope. Plain white paper, the stamp slightly crooked.
*“Dear Grandma,”* Sam wrote. *“Thank you for the Christmas card and the twenty dollars you always gave me. About the check—I haven't cashed it. It’s sitting in my desk drawer between the pages of Dad’s old Bible. I still don’t feel right spending it. Mr. Miller gave me a fifty-cent raise at the hardware store, so I’m doing fine for rent. The brass key is on my keychain. I shoveled your driveway early Thursday morning before my shift so the mailman wouldn’t slip. I didn’t want to knock and wake you up. I hope your knee isn’t hurting too bad with the frost. Love, Sam.”*
Edith held Sam’s note for a long time. Her thumb rubbed against the graphite marks of his pencil. She could picture him in the dark, five in the morning, his breath pluming in the thirty-below chill, quietly scraping snow off her porch steps so she wouldn’t take a fall.
A sudden knock on the front door shattered the silence.
Edith did not hurry. She placed all three letters into the green shoebox, slid the lid shut, and walked slowly to the foyer, leaning lightly on her polished hickory cane. She peered through the lace curtain of the window.
Standing on the porch was Brittany. She was dressed in an oversized beige teddy bear coat, dark sunglasses pushed up onto her highlighted hair, holding a bakery box tied with pink ribbon in one hand. In the other hand, partially concealed against her hip, was her iPhone, positioned at a low angle with its front-facing camera active.
Edith unlocked the deadbolt and pulled the heavy wooden door open.
“Grandma!” Brittany cried out with exaggerated ecstasy. She stepped forward immediately, arms outstretched, clearly angling her body toward the phone’s lens. “Look at you! Oh, I’ve missed you so much! I brought you those almond tarts from that artisan bakery down on 4th Street!”
Edith took half a step back, preventing the embrace. Her eyes dropped immediately to the glowing red recording icon on the screen Brittany was holding.
“Brittany,” Edith said calmly. “Who is that little red light for?”
Brittany froze, her smile hitching for a fraction of a second before recovering. “Oh, this? Nothing, Grandma! You know I do my ‘Day in the Life’ vlogs! My followers were so touched by the story of how much I miss you. They just want to see us hug!”
“I am an old woman, Brittany, not a prop for your digital carnival,” Edith said, her voice dropping into a tone of quiet steel. “Turn it off. Put it in your pocket. Or take your almond tarts and eat them in your car.”
Brittany’s cheeks burned crimson. With a sharp, resentful jerk of her thumb, she tapped the screen, terminated the recording, and jammed the phone deep into her coat pocket. The manufactured warmth vanished from her eyes, replaced instantly by the cold, calculating glare of an opportunist who had just been caught.
“There,” Brittany snapped, stepping uninvited into the foyer and tracking wet slush onto the hardwood floor. “It’s off. Are you happy now? God, you treat me like a criminal! I drove forty-five minutes in the snow just to see you!”
May you like
“You drove forty-five minutes to see if fifty thousand dollars was still on the table,” Edith replied, closing the door behind her with a definitive click. “Take off your boots. You’re ruining the varnish.”
***
